The Most Iconic Baseball Games of All Time
and What Their Ticket Stubs Are Worth TodayÂ
For diehard baseball fans, few things are more meaningful than holding a ticket stub from a legendary game. These little slips of paper can be worth hundreds — sometimes thousands — of dollars. But more than that, they represent history you could hold in your hand.
Whether you’re a collector or just curious, here’s a look at some of the most iconic baseball games ever played — and what those ticket stubs are worth today.
⚾ Game 5, 1956 World Series — Don Larsen’s Perfect Game
Why It’s Iconic: The only perfect game in World Series history, thrown by Don Larsen for the Yankees.
Stub Value: Full tickets often fetch $2,000–$4,000. Even torn stubs can go for $500+.
Collector Note: Condition matters, but so does story. This is one of the most sought-after stubs in baseball history.
⚾ Game 7, 1960 World Series — Mazeroski’s Walk-Off
Why It’s Iconic: Bill Mazeroski hit the only Game 7 walk-off home run in World Series history, giving the Pirates the win over the Yankees.
Stub Value: Around $500–$2,000 depending on condition.
Collector Note: The dramatic finish makes this one a grail item for Pirates fans.
⚾ Cal Ripken Jr.’s 2,131st Game — September 6, 1995
Why It’s Iconic: Ripken broke Lou Gehrig’s streak for most consecutive games played.
Stub Value: $100–$500, but framed or autographed versions can command more.
Collector Note: A fan favorite because of what it represents: longevity, loyalty, and grit.
⚾ Game 6, 1975 World Series — Fisk Waves It Fair
Why It’s Iconic: Carlton Fisk’s 12th-inning home run and iconic wave created one of baseball’s most replayed moments.
Stub Value: Around $300–$1,200 depending on condition.
Collector Note: Extremely popular with Red Sox collectors — and sports photographers.
⚾ Game 7, 2016 World Series — Cubs Finally Win
Why It’s Iconic: The Cubs ended a 108-year drought with an unforgettable Game 7 win over Cleveland.
Stub Value: $300–$1,000 and climbing, especially for unused or graded versions.
Collector Note: One of the few modern stubs to appreciate quickly — nostalgia came fast.
⚾ Barry Bonds’ 756th Home Run — August 7, 2007
Why It’s Iconic: Bonds broke Hank Aaron’s all-time home run record.
Stub Value: $150–$700
Collector Note: Controversial, but still historic. Some fans actively seek both this and Aaron’s 715th HR stub.
Why Stub Collecting Is Heating Up
As teams go fully digital, old ticket stubs are becoming rarer by the year. That scarcity is fueling demand for physical keepsakes from unforgettable games. Whether you went to the game or just want to own a piece of it, stubs are a tangible connection to baseball’s greatest moments.
Want a Commemorative Stub of Your Own?
Even if your game wasn’t a no-hitter or a walk-off homer, it meant something to you. That’s why we help fans design their own custom commemorative ticket stubs — personalized with your seat, date, and photos from the day.
Because sometimes, just being there is enough to make it iconic.
Explore your own custom ticket stub at Fanstubs.shop