The Most Valuable Ticket Stubs Ever Sold

The Most Valuable Ticket Stubs Ever Sold

What Makes Them Worth Thousands 

To most people, a ticket stub is just a scrap of paper. To collectors, it can be worth tens of thousands of dollars.

In recent years, ticket stubs from historic sports moments have sold for eye-popping amounts at auction. But it’s not just about age or condition — it’s about the story behind the stub.

Here are some of the highest ticket stub sales of all time — and what made them so valuable.

🎟️ Jackie Robinson’s MLB Debut — April 15, 1947

Sale Price: $480,000 (2022)
Why It’s Valuable: This isn’t just a baseball game — it’s one of the most important cultural moments in American history. Robinson’s debut with the Brooklyn Dodgers broke MLB’s color barrier.
Collector Takeaway: Cultural significance drives collector demand, especially when tied to broader historical impact.

🎟️ Babe Ruth’s First MLB Game — July 11, 1914

Sale Price: $137,000
Why It’s Valuable: The birth of a legend. Ruth’s first major league appearance for the Boston Red Sox makes this one of the earliest surviving stubs tied to the most iconic player in baseball history.
Collector Takeaway: Firsts matter — especially when they involve household names like Ruth, Jordan, or Brady.

🎟️ Lou Gehrig’s “Luckiest Man” Speech — July 4, 1939

Sale Price: $95,600
Why It’s Valuable: The ticket isn’t from a thrilling win or a big moment on the field — it’s from a farewell. Gehrig’s emotional retirement speech at Yankee Stadium is one of the most replayed moments in baseball history.
Collector Takeaway: Emotional resonance often trumps on-field results.

🎟️ Game 3, 1903 World Series — First World Series Game in Boston

Sale Price: $175,000
Why It’s Valuable: This stub comes from the first modern World Series between the Boston Americans and Pittsburgh Pirates. It’s a tangible piece of the beginning of a new era.
Collector Takeaway: “First ever” stubs in league history are among the most reliably valuable.

🎟️ Mickey Mantle’s First Game — April 17, 1951

Sale Price: $141,000
Why It’s Valuable: While Mantle didn’t become an icon overnight, this stub marks the debut of one of the most beloved Yankees of all time.
Collector Takeaway: Rookie debuts and future Hall of Famers always carry long-term value.

What Drives a Ticket Stub’s Value?

Collectors consider several factors:

  • Historical Significance – Cultural or game-changing moments carry more emotional and monetary weight.

  • Rarity – Many early 1900s stubs were thrown away. Survivors are scarce.

  • Condition – Crisp edges, full stubs (not torn), and legibility boost auction prices.

  • Authentication – PSA or other grading services can dramatically increase value.

  • Player or Team Connection – The bigger the star or the more storied the franchise, the more collectors care.

But above all — it’s the story.

Want to Hold on to Your Own Story?

While most of us don’t have a Gehrig or Ruth stub lying around, we all have our own iconic fan moments — and they deserve to be remembered.

At FanStubs, we help fans turn everyday game days into collectible moments. Custom ticket stubs with your seat, your photos, and your story.

Because it might not be in Cooperstown — but it’s priceless to you.

Back to blog